weiblich gelesene person mittig bekommt von der seite von sechs händen verschiedene verhütungsmittel gereicht, person hält sich hand seitlich schützend vor die augen

Hormone-Free Contraception - Alternative to the Pill

Hormonal contraception is out. More and more people are looking for a safe, well-tolerated method of contraception that does not interfere with the natural cycle. There are many hormone-free contraceptive options.

In this article...

...you will learn about the different hormone-free methods of contraception.

...you will discover all the advantages and disadvantages of the different hormone-free methods of contraception.

Hormonal contraception is out! At least, that is what the latest survey by the Federal Centre for Health Education (BZgA) suggests. It found that more and more people, and women in particular (author’s note: The study results use a binary definition of gender. We therefore cannot make the results gender-inclusive, as we have no details about gender identity), are generally opposed to hormonal contraceptive methods: while only 1% felt this way in 2011, the figure had risen to 15% by 2023. In addition, more than half of those surveyed (men and women) believe that hormonal contraception has a negative effect on physical and mental health. Health concerns in particular, along with the desire for safe, well-tolerated contraception, mean that condoms are now used more frequently than the pill for the first time. 

Overall, 91% of respondents use the pill and/or condoms. But besides condoms, there are many other hormone-free contraceptive methods available. What they all have in common is that they contain no synthetic hormones and therefore do not interfere with the natural cycle. However, they differ greatly in their advantages and disadvantages, and not all of them are recommended. We’d like to support you in stopping hormonal contraception, but we also want to make sure you’re well informed when making this decision. So below, you’ll find brief profiles of the most common hormone-free contraceptive methods. For more information, we recommend the detailed articles in our magazine, the information portals listed under References and, of course, your gynecologist’s office.

Mechanical contraceptives

The best-known hormone-free contraceptive methods are probably mechanical contraceptives, which prevent sperm from reaching the vagina or the egg. They are also called barrier methods. According to the Pearl Index, they are among the more reliable contraceptive methods. Below, we briefly explain how condoms, female condoms, diaphragms, cervical caps, copper IUDs and copper chains work, along with their advantages and disadvantages.

hand perceived as female opening a silver condom wrapper

Condom 

The condom is the only contraceptive method for the penis. It is a tube-shaped, ultra-thin, tear-resistant latex sheath that is rolled over an erect penis. Semen is collected in the closed tip, preventing it from entering the vagina. Latex-free condoms are also available.

Pearl Index** for condoms:

2-12
Advantages of condoms
Disadvantages of condoms
  • the only contraceptive method besides the female condom that also protects against sexually transmitted infections
  • readily available without a doctor’s prescription
  • relatively reliable when used correctly (including choosing the right size)
  • only needs to be used when needed
  • can alter sensation during sex
  • can tear unnoticed during sex
  • cannot be reused


Female condom 

The female condom is the equivalent of the condom for women. It looks similar: a very thin plastic tube that is closed at one end. Unlike a regular condom, the female condom has plastic rings at both ends. The smaller ring is inserted into the vagina and covers the cervix; the larger ring prevents the female condom from slipping into the vagina by sitting at the vaginal opening. The female condom is inserted into the vagina before sex. Using lubricant is recommended.

Pearl Index** for the female condom:

5-25

Advantages of the female condom
Disadvantages of the female condom
  • the only contraceptive method that enables women* to protect themselves from sexually transmitted infections
  • can be inserted before sex
  • rather difficult to use; the female condom can slip into the vagina or be pulled out during sex
  • can alter sensation during sex
  • each female condom can only be used once


hands perceived as female holding a purple diaphragm

Diaphragm

A diaphragm is a small cup made of a flexible ring and soft silicone membrane. It is placed over the cervix before sex to block sperm from entering. A spermicide is used along with the diaphragm to alter the pH in the vagina so that sperm can no longer move.


Pearl Index** for the diaphragm:

1 - 20

Advantages of the diaphragm
Disadvantages of the diaphragm
  • can be inserted up to 2 hours before sex
  • invisible during sex
  • usually lasts for 2 years and can be reused
  • prone to user error; insertion takes practice
  • medical advice is needed to select the right size
  • must be used together with spermicide
  • may be noticeable
  • does not protect against sexually transmitted infections



Cervical cap

The cervical cap, or contraceptive cap, works like the diaphragm but is somewhat firmer and fits more snugly over the cervix. It is placed over the cervix and held in place by suction. Its effectiveness increases when used with spermicide.

 

Pearl Index** for the cervical cap:

6

Advantages of the cervical cap
Disadvantages of the cervical cap
  • can be inserted before sex
  • invisible during sex
  • can be reused
  • prone to user error
  • must not be removed until 6–8 hours after sex
  • requires fitting by a doctor
  • does not protect against sexually transmitted infections


smiling person perceived as female holding a copper IUD in one hand and pointing to it with the other

Copper IUD

A copper IUD is a T-shaped plastic device wrapped with copper wire that is inserted into the uterus. By releasing copper ions, it changes the composition of the uterine lining and cervical mucus so that sperm cannot pass through them or a potentially fertilized egg cannot implant.

 

Pearl Index** for the copper IUD:

0.3 - 0.8 

Advantages of the copper IUD
Disadvantages of the copper IUD
  • long-term protection (3–10 years) after a single insertion
  • invisible and usually not noticeable during sex
  • involves a high one-time cost
  • requires an invasive medical procedure, which can be painful
  • the copper IUD may be rejected after insertion, fall out during a period or shift out of place; the associated costs are not reimbursed
  • regular medical check-ups are needed to ensure it is correctly positioned, which may incur additional costs
  • may cause heavier menstrual bleeding or cramps and increase susceptibility to infections in the pelvic area
  • does not protect against sexually transmitted infections


 

Like the copper IUD, the copper ball is another option, though there is less data available on its effectiveness, safety and side effects.

Copper chain

The copper chain works in the same way as the copper IUD. It consists of small copper cylinders threaded onto a nylon string that release copper ions. Unlike the IUD, the copper chain is anchored in the uterine muscle. 

Pearl Index** for the copper chain:

0.1 - 0.5

Advantages of the copper chain:
Disadvantages of the copper chain:
  • long-term protection
  • lower risk of rejection, falling out or shifting compared with the copper IUD
  • can also be used by young women with a small uterus
  • associated with high one-time costs
  • requires an invasive medical procedure by an experienced doctor, which can be painful
  • the copper IUD may be rejected after insertion, and the costs for this are not reimbursed
  • proper placement requires regular medical check-ups, which can incur additional costs
  • can lead to heavier menstrual bleeding or cramps and an increased susceptibility to infections in the lower abdomen
  • does not protect against sexually transmitted diseases


 

Chemical contraceptives

Chemical contraceptives include creams, suppositories, gels, or foam products for vaginal use. They contain spermicides, i.e., substances that kill sperm. Since they offer only a low level of protection according to the Pearl Index, they should always be used with mechanical contraceptive methods. When combined correctly, they can increase the effectiveness of these contraceptives. 


Pearl Index** of chemical contraceptives:

3 - 21

Advantage of chemical contraceptives
Disadvantage of chemical contraceptives
  • When used correctly, they increase the effectiveness of condoms, diaphragms, copper IUDs, etc. (provided that the chemical products do not affect the material)
  • available over the counter at pharmacies
  • offer only a low level of protection when used alone
  • must be inserted into the vagina 20 minutes before sexual intercourse and are only effective for 1 hour
  • can damage the material of mechanical contraceptives
  • can cause allergies, irritation, burning, and infections by damaging the vaginal lining
  • do not protect against sexually transmitted diseases



Symptothermal method

The symptothermal method assesses a woman's fertility based on various characteristics. Her basal body temperature is measured and recorded every morning before getting out of bed. The consistency of her cervical mucus and changes in her cervix are also observed. There are various criteria that provide information about the time in the cycle. When used correctly, the symptothermal method offers a high level of protection. It is therefore used primarily in natural family planning to identify fertile days. As a contraceptive method, it requires that other forms of contraception be used on potentially fertile days and that cycle-affecting circumstances such as illness, shift work, time zone changes, stress, etc. be taken into account.


Pearl Index** of the symptothermal method:

0.4-1.8

Temperature measurement alone 0.8 - 3

Advantage of the symptothermal method: 
Advantage of the symptothermal method: 
  • very reliable when used correctly
  • increases awareness of natural cyclical changes
  • enables the identification of fertile days when trying to conceive
  • requires discipline and careful observation
  • can be easily affected by changes in daily routine or illness, difficult to implement with shift work
  • does not protect against sexually transmitted diseases
  • Additional contraception on fertile days with another contraceptive method is necessary (e.g., condom, diaphragm, etc.)


Calendar method

The calendar method estimates the approximate time in the cycle based on a model cycle of 28 days and the first day of the last period. This method is therefore highly uncertain, as very few women* have a 28-day cycle or a regular cycle in general. The location of fertile days is thus hardly predictable.


Pearl Index** of the calendar method:

3-9

Advantage of the calendar method
Disadvantage of the calendar method
  • enables the rough identification of fertile days when trying to conceive
  • cannot be applied to most women* and is therefore uncertain
  • cyclical fluctuations are not taken into account
  • does not protect against sexually transmitted diseases



Sterilization

If it is certain that a person does not want to conceive or receive children in the future, sterilization can be an option for conventional contraception. In men*, the vas deferens are severed (vasectomy). The seminal fluid no longer contains sperm. In women*, the fallopian tubes are severed or closed (tubal ligation). Eggs can no longer travel to the uterus or sperm to the fallopian tubes.


Pearl Index** of sterilization:

Tubal ligation 0.2-0.3

Vasectomy 0.1

 

Advantage of sterilization
Disadvantage of sterilization
  • very reliable
  • difficult or impossible to reverse
  • requires extensive medical and psychological counseling before agreeing to surgery, depending on gender and age
  • invasive procedure with associated risks (vasectomy is lower risk than tubal ligation)
  • very high one-time costs (vasectomy is more affordable than tubal ligation)
  • risk of ectopic pregnancy with tubal ligation 


The agony of choice

No contraceptive method, not even hormonal ones, is 100% certain. Inform yourself fully before choosing your contraceptive method and also seek medical advice. The choice of a contraceptive is an individual decision and depends on circumstances such as desire for children, relationship status, working hours, travel habits, and of course your health and any health restrictions. Not every contraceptive method is suitable for every situation or person.

By choosing hormone-free contraception, you take a step toward a healthy, natural cycle and avoid the side effects that synthetic hormones can bring. Nevertheless, choosing hormonal contraception may also be the right or necessary choice in your life situation. Ultimately, only you need to feel comfortable and safe with the contraceptive method you choose. Do not let yourself be forced or persuaded into a method that does not feel right for you - neither by your partner nor by your doctor!

**What is the Pearl Index?

The Pearl Index is a unit of measurement that indicates how many women become pregnant within a year despite using a specific contraceptive method. Briefly put, this definition conceals the reliability of a contraceptive method. The lower the Pearl Index, the safer the contraceptive method. For unprotected, regular sexual intercourse, the Pearl Index is 92-82 depending on the age of the sexually mature woman. 

The Pearl Index assumes correct use of the contraceptive method, so user errors further reduce the effectiveness of the contraceptive method.

weiblich gelesene hand reicht männlich gelesener hand ein rotes kondom in verpackung

Did you know that?

Condoms are more popular than the pill!

The Federal Center for Health Education (BZgA) regularly carries out various studies on health behavior. In 2023, the contraceptive behavior of adults in Germany was updated. In this survey, for the first time since the survey, the condom was more popular than the pill as a hormone-free contraceptive. Even though both methods are still the most frequently used, the condom took first place with 53% of those surveyed, overtaking the pill with 38%. The BZgA sees the reason for this in an increasingly critical attitude towards hormonal contraception, the increasing importance of health aspects and the desire for good tolerability. 61% of women and men believe that hormonal contraception has negative effects on the body and soul. Interesting: 15% of women who use contraception have a general rejection of the pill or hormonal contraception, particularly in the 18-29 age group. In 2011 it was only 1%. [1]

(Author's note: The study results use the binary gender definition. We therefore cannot gender the results as we do not have any details on gender)

weiblich gelesene hand reicht männlich gelesener hand ein rotes kondom in verpackung

Did you know that?

Condoms are more popular than the pill!

The Federal Center for Health Education (BZgA) regularly carries out various studies on health behavior. In 2023, the contraceptive behavior of adults in Germany was updated. In this survey, for the first time since the survey, the condom was more popular than the pill as a hormone-free contraceptive. Even though both methods are still the most frequently used, the condom took first place with 53% of those surveyed, overtaking the pill with 38%. The BZgA sees the reason for this in an increasingly critical attitude towards hormonal contraception, the increasing importance of health aspects and the desire for good tolerability. 61% of women and men believe that hormonal contraception has negative effects on the body and soul. Interesting: 15% of women who use contraception have a general rejection of the pill or hormonal contraception, particularly in the 18-29 age group. In 2011 it was only 1%. [1]

(Author's note: The study results use the binary gender definition. We therefore cannot gender the results as we do not have any details on gender)

Did you know that?

These 4 organs are particularly affected by side effects of the pill

You can reduce the side effects of stopping the pill by paying special attention to 4 organs during this time.

farbliche Illustration einer leber

Liver

Is responsible for the breakdown of synthetic hormones. Increases the production of sex hormone-binding globulins while taking the pill, which can lead to hormone imbalances.

farbliche Illustration der nebennieren

Adrenal glands

Respond to the inflammation caused by the pill with the constant release of stress hormones such as cortisol, which can promote adrenal exhaustion.

farbliche Illustration eines darms

Colon

Is particularly affected by the inflammatory reactions caused by the pill, which can lead to leaky gut syndrome with inflammation, autoimmune reactions and allergies.

farbliche Illustration einer schilddrüse

Thyroid

May show symptoms of hypothyroidism because the pill causes increased production of thyroid hormone-binding globulins.

natural: 100%- Natürliche Zutaten- Vegan-
Glutenfrei- Laktosefrei- Ohne Zusatzstoffe

3 packungen reset und ein aufbewahrungsglas im fenou design mit dem reset ratgeber

Can we recommend something to you?

stop pill bundle

Is stopping the pill already on your to-do list? So that you don't have to worry about side effects such as hormonal hair loss, skin blemishes and acne, we have put together a unique bundle consisting of our popular reset for stopping the pill and our informative guide with recipes, tips, applications and cycle diary.

Still curious?

Would you like your contraception to be hormone-free, but are not sure whether and what side effects you can expect when you stop using your current hormonal contraception? In our article “Stopping the pill without side effects” we explain potential side effects and give you tips on how you can reduce them. You will also find detailed information about reset, our unique nutritional supplement for stopping the pill.

For Further Reading

References

[1]https://www.bzga.de/fileadmin/user_upload/PDF/pressemitteilungen/daten_und_fakten/Infoblatt_BZgA-Studiendaten_Verhütungsverhalten_2023.pdf
https://www.profamilia.de/fileadmin/beratungsstellen/pforzheim/45.pdf, accessed on 1/19/24
https://www.familienplanung.de/verhuetung/verhuetungsmethoden/, accessed 1/19/24
https://www.frauenaerzte-im-netz.de/familienplanung-verhuetung/, accessed on 1/19/24

fenou supports acceptance and equality in society!

When we talk about “women,” we mean anyone who identifies as a woman and/or has female sex organs from a biological perspective. However, our work is based on the sex hormones that circulate in the human body when a uterus and/or ovaries are present. Therefore, our articles and products may not apply to you, even though you identify as a woman. We are also aware that not everyone with female sex organs identifies as a woman. We also want to reach out to people who do not identify as female (such as transgender, intersex, and non-binary people) with our informative posts and by no means want to exclude them. We use gender-neutral language in our posts whenever possible and are continuously educating ourselves. So please feel free to contact us if you have constructive suggestions for more inclusive language!